Airbus A220 'Whisperjet' is too loud, according to Zurich residents

We’re sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. We’re working to restore it. Please try again later.

Advertisement

This was published 5 years ago

Airbus A220 'Whisperjet' is too loud, according to Zurich residents

Airbus A220 was formerly the Bombardier C Series plane.

Airbus A220 was formerly the Bombardier C Series plane.Credit: AP

Airline Swiss greeted the arrival of its latest plane with great fanfare, dubbing the Airbus A220 model the "Whisperjet" and promising neighbourhoods around Zurich Airport that it would be 50 per cent quieter than older aircraft.

But that tag has come back to haunt the Lufthansa unit as the narrow-body's twin engines emit what locals have described as a strange howling noise as it comes in to land, enraging people living on the flight path.

"It's even louder than other machines flying in," said Klaus Stoehlker, spokesman for the Zurich-based Foundation Against Aircraft Noise. "They've been describing it as temporary while they make assessments, but for nine months now it hasn't gone away."

Airbus and Swiss each said they are aware of the situation and in close contact with engine maker Pratt & Whitney, which is analysing the noise -- likened by some to the mating call of an orca whale -- to determine its cause.

Airbus and Swiss each said they are aware of the situation and in close contact with engine maker Pratt & Whitney, which is analysing the noise -- likened by some to the mating call of an orca whale -- to determine its cause.Credit: Bloomberg

Zurich Airport has received complaints on its noise hotline of unusual sounds when the A220 passes overhead, a spokeswoman said, adding that it's working with Swiss to seek a quick solution. The plane -- developed by Bombardier and now part of the Airbus lineup -- isn't breaching rules and the sound, which last for a few seconds, hasn't triggered higher fees that apply to louder jets.

Airbus and Swiss each said they are aware of the situation and in close contact with engine maker Pratt & Whitney, which is analysing the noise -- likened by some to the mating call of an orca whale -- to determine its cause. The sound "occasionally occurs" during throttle movements when A220 is at low power, a Pratt spokeswoman said, adding that the jet's total noise footprint still represents a 75 per cent improvement on older planes.

The issue, which affects A220 models seemingly at random, risks blemishing the plane's credentials as ideal for noise-limited airports. Hubs including Frankfurt operate strict night curfews, while London City, which Swiss also serves with the plane, restricts weekend flights.

The Whisperjet name has been applied to a variety of planes over the decades, including the BAE-146 and Eastern Airlines Boeing 727s, whose tail-mounted engines made the front of the cabin quiet but the rear especially noisy.

Airbus and Bombardier first announced their tie-up last October as Canadian jetmaker Bombardier looked for a resolution to a trade dispute in which the United States threatened tariffs of up to 300 per cent on the CSeries jets. The threatened tariffs followed a formal complaint launched by Boeing that alleged unfair subsidies for the Canadian-made jet, which was buoyed by a large order from Atlanta-based Delta.

Advertisement

The United States ultimately confirmed unfair subsidies, but backed off the tariffs because it said Boeing could not prove harm from them. However, that didn't come before Bombardier sought refuge in a deal with Boeing's archrival Airbus that would allow US-bound CSeries jets to be assembled at Airbus' recently opened assembly line in Alabama. The deal ended up giving Airbus a majority stake in the CSeries line.

Since then, Boeing has followed up plans to cement its own partnership with Bombardier's Brazilian-based rival Embraer, further extending the rivalry between Boeing and Airbus.

Bombardier and Embraer have traditionally focused mostly on regional jets, but each has introduced new lines of planes that can seat roughly 100 to 150 passengers, depending on the model and configuration. That new lineup of planes has brought the regional jetmaker's planes right up to the cusp of the smallest models offered by Boeing (the 737) and Airbus (the A320 family).

Bloomberg/TNS

See also: Airbus unveils its 'new' series of jets, the A220s

Sign up for the Traveller Deals newsletter

Get exclusive travel deals delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up now.

Most viewed on Traveller

Loading